$1.2 Million Payment Looms for District Judge
Friday, December 23rd, 2011
Judge Mark Somers
In case you missed it, the jury verdict against 19th District Chief Judge Mark Somers was upheld by a U.S. District judge, which means the Dearborn judge is now looking at a total bill of roughly $1.2 million when interest and attorney fees are factored in to the original award.
Judge Somers had filed a motion to set aside the $732,361 jury verdict against him but U.S. District Judge David Lawson denied the appeal last week. This long-running case pitted 19th District Deputy Court Administrator Julie Pucci against Somers, her former boss.
Somers told the Dearborn Press & Guide that while he is “disappointed” with the recent outcome, he isn’t ready to concede defeat.
“I am understandably disappointed in the outcome of the motions,” Somers told the Press & Guide. “I believe that they were meritorious and I have already requested that the Attorney General’s Office initiate the appeals process.”
The state Attorney General’s Office, per Michigan law, provides legal defense for judges who are sued for something they do as part of their job.
It isn’t clear who will ultimately write the check for the roughly $1.2 million for this case.
Somers says Dearborn will be responsible. City attorneys have said the city is not responsible for the payment.
U.S. District Judge Lawson said the matter of who will end up paying will likely have to be settled in court.
“The more likely scenario is that Dearborn’s obligation to pay the judgment will have to be litigated,” Lawson wrote. “In the meantime, the judgment will remain against the defendant in his individual capacity, and he has not demonstrated that his ‘ability to pay the judgment is so plain that the cost of the bond would be a waste of money.’”
And to think this case could have been settled for less than $40,000, roughly the amount of Julie Pucci’s salary.

Dearborn residents should be aware that the curbside trash and recycling pickup schedules will be delayed one day for the weeks of Dec. 26-30 and Jan. 2-6.